2027 Vegetable Sowing Calendar - Order now!
Read-only archive of the Charles Dowding forum, 2009–2019. For Charles’s latest advice, visit charlesdowding.co.uk.

Forum archive›General Gardening›Sowing and Growing›2 days before vs 2 days after full moon for sowing….

2 days before vs 2 days after full moon for sowing….

Asked by Rhys 3 March 2016 7 replies in Sowing and Growing

Charles answered Charles replied once in this thread. Jump to his answer ↓

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  1. #33460

    Charles

    Apologies if this has been covered somewhere else (if it has, I apologise but I’ve not read it to date), but I was wondering:

    In previous years, you have done a variety of experiments comparing sowing/planting two days before full moon vs two days after for a few types of vegetables.

    I was wondering: did your higher results occur if sow date was the right ‘biodynamic day’ i.e. root, fruit, leaf? Or was there no discernible effect of that?

    I ask as there are some months in sowing season when 2 days before full moon is the ‘wrong’ biodynamic day but two days after is the right one.

    As an example: full moon in March 2016 is the 23rd:

    2 days before is a fruit day – so perfect for sowing tomatoes, peas etc.

    2 days after is apparently unfavourable according to the Thun calendar, but one day after is root in the morning and leaf in the afternoon.

    So there is a dilemma as to whether to plant carrots 2 days before on a fruit day, one day before on a root day or one day after on a root day.

    In April, two days before full moon (22nd) is a root day, which is thus optimal for various carrot sowings, maybe potatoes too. Maybe radish and beetroot too.

    However, two days after is a leaf day, which wouldn’t normally be when you would sow lettuce seeds.

    I have no attachment to any particular theory, method etc. Just interested in whether you have data to compare the lunar cycle with the biodynamic cycle??

  2. #33463

    Thanks Rhys and to clarity, I sow two days after as comparison only, I don’t reckon it a favourable time to sow.
    Your question is fair and I don’t understand the discrepancies between root-flower-leaf-fruit, and waxing-waning.
    Maria Thun and Nick Kollerstrom make more of the former and little of the latter.
    Whereas older farmers I have know look at waxing-waning and also ascending-descending. So there is a third aspect!! In France I was advised in no uncertain terms to prune vines on a descending moon, and they knew nothing of fruit days which as far as I can see were (recently) discovered by Maria Thun.
    Its nice when they coincide e.g. sow tomatoes on 21st as you mention.
    And last year my March carrot sowing favoured the root day.
    But each year the results are variable and other factors are involved as well as the moon changes.
    From my newsletter I had these responses:

    I once did an experiment with some seeds while I was still working. A co worker said nothing germinated for her. So we did an experiment with some tomatoes. I provided the seeds one packet, and the potting compost, and the plastic cups came from the coffee machine. And yes all my seeds germinated and none of hers. So I potting on the results and gave half to her and yes! mine thrived and hers died. The only different was she was about one floor higher than me. (from Neil, thanks)

    and
    Hi i liked your brief mention on planting by the moon. here in Umbria this is done as a matter of course. Nearby in Spello there is a garden open to the public that specialises and gives lectures on this subject with a free Almanac (from Janice, thanks)

  3. #33464

    Hello Rhys and Charles,

    I am glad that this topic was raised too. I am now referring to my 2013 copy of Nick kollerstrom’s calendar. And the chapter on The Moon and Fertility, there is a graph on water uptake by bean seeds (seed germination) and it showed that even a few days after full moon, it appears that the seed germination rate is still higher compared to the days following new moon. Although it is gradually decreasing. It can be rather confusing. Perhaps a maximum of 2-3 days after full moon would give a decent germination rate too ? What are your thoughts about it?

  4. #33467

    Hi Karen

    I must say there is the possibility for novices to become totally confused if they do too much reading! All kinds of different advice, depending on source.

    For example, I read on the internet (can’t remember more than I was searching under ‘Sowing seeds biodynamically’) that:
    1. For best balanced leaf growth (salads and brassicas) plant in the first 7 days after new moon.
    2. For plants which produce fruit above ground (peas, beans, tomatoes etc), plant in the second quarter up to full moon.
    3. For root plants (potato, carrot etc), plant in the 3rd quarter after full moon.
    4. Don’t plant anything in the 4th quarter prior to the next new moon.

    What I’m not finding are the gardening/farming equivalent to scientific papers where experiments have been done comparing in a rigorous manner. They may exist, but they aren’t attuned to google searches! I may have to try some traditional science paper search engines….

    All I’ve found in one season of trying things out is that I found lettuce germinated fantastically two days before full moon and that tomatoes do well when germinated on fruit days with the moon in Leo.

    I’m trying a few things out this year, but not in formal experiments as I simply don’t have the capacity to do it……

  5. #33472

    I know the exactly feeling Rhys! So many theories… too little known results.

    I am definitely going to try the 2-3 days before full moon and also in conjuction with the right plant part. I am especially curious to know if the lettuce will truly germinate quick! Fingers crossed!

    Thanks for your insight… have a wonderful weekend 🙂

  6. #33487

    Karen

    Here’s an interesting read: http://www.bachbiodynamics.com/uploads/1/6/3/6/16367710/2016__biodynamic_planting_calendar_.pdf

    Pretty good data for sowing carrots two days before full moon (Charles has also found this). I’m also very interested in the role of Perigee and Apogee, but the data I’ve found to date seems very contradictory.

    I”m cautious about putting all eggs into the Perigee basket currently…….

  7. #33492

    :0

    cheers Rhys!

    That´s gonna be an interesting read for sure!

    I usually have some kind of buffer when I sow and plant to diversify and spread any kind of risk…. e.g. sowing different varieties of parsley or from different suppliers in case of poor germination rates as we need loads of this herb.

    I guess with time and experience and lots of experiments that we will know somewhat what works best! 🙂 and as proven by Charles.

  8. #33493

    Oh… the report certainly brings backs memories of those crazy assignments I had to write back in Uni! Ha!

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)

Want to go further?

→ Free: Charles’s sowing timeline