2027 Vegetable Sowing Calendar - Order now!
Read-only archive of the Charles Dowding forum, 2009–2019. For Charles’s latest advice, visit charlesdowding.co.uk.

Forum archive›No dig gardening›Preparing the ground›Beginner needing to know how to deal with horse tail and bindweed.

Beginner needing to know how to deal with horse tail and bindweed.

Asked by Herb Woman 28 March 2016 14 replies in Preparing the ground

Charles answered Charles replied 4 times in this thread. Jump to his answer ↓

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  1. #33711

    Am really excited about going no-dig, read the getting started article and saw that my two (main ) perennial weeds, horse tail and bind weed were highlighted as being too tenacious to die when covered with 15cm of manure/compost.. I need advice on how to proceed. Will I need to mulch then miss a year’s veg growing in order to kill these off?

    Looking forward to your word of wisdom as I will need a personal osteopath if I have to dig any more!

  2. #33712

    Hi Herb Woman. I was faced with a similar situation at my allotment plot when I took it on three and a half years ago. I followed Charles advice and mulched with manure and then 800 grade black polythene. I chose to leave my mulch in place for two full seasons as the horsetail was so well established; I dug and cropped about a third of my plot whilst this mulching took place. I am now cropping most of my plot and, although there is some regrowth, the horsetail and bind weed is so weak that it easy to remove with regular trowel patrols during their growing season. This has kept up my morale whilst I learnt about growing and was a long-term solution to a rather tricky situation.

    I hope this helps.

  3. #33713

    I removed field bindweed by digging (I had to anyway for various reasons) which pulled out tens of metres of root if not more, then over several years pulling it out whenever shoots appeared. It has now gone. But it had huge amounts of root and can survive years of being pulled out. Composting suppresses most weeds, making it easy to spot the bindweed.

    As for horsetail, I have read that growing turnip helps, but having never had it, I don’t really know!

  4. #33715

    Thanks Stringfellow and Leif. I have been growing veg on this plot for about 10 years, and the beds where I have worked most have a bit less horsetail and bind weed than the fruit bushes patch, so digging has helped a bit. I feel loathed to leave my plot uncultivated for two seasons, but will do it if I have to.

    If anyone else has any suggestions though……. will look into the turnips, even though none of my family eat them!

    Enjoy this lovely spring .

  5. #33716

    I have tried few things equivalent to turnips, such as Tagetes minute against couch grass, and have not been impressed with results.
    Tris’ plan is best IMO. Two ways to mitigate loss of space:
    1 add extra compost to a small, intensive cropped area where you can grow many veg that grow at close spacing, and be super thorough on weeds
    2 Plant a few squash, courgette and any wide spaced veg through holes in the poly-covered area so its cropped a bit. Be sure to pull any weeds popping up through the holes.

  6. #33720

    I assume from your reply that horse tail is endemic in the area, not just in your plot? Then surely in that case you cannot remove it, just control it, since there is always a ‘mother patch’. They say it goes down a long way, so you can’t even put down a vertical barrier, as I did for hedge bindweed.

  7. #33723

    Leif, am hoping I don’t have the mother patch! Havn’t noticed much around, but I am probably not the only one.

    Charles, Tris’ plan?

    Thanks for your input.

  8. #33725

    Hi again. Tris – c’est moi. You could Mulch for one Season and See how Strong regrowth is – it depends how much Time and Motivation you have for weeding! As suggested, you could Mulch some of your Plot whilst cropping the rest.

    My Plan is Charles Brain Child really. Good luck!

  9. #33726

    Tris’ plan is string fellow’s first post!

  10. #33729

    Three and half years have raced by, so if you are thinking of an asparagus bed or similar long termer (fruit trees?) get them in this season and they’ll be on the table before ya know it!

  11. #33797

    We took on a bindweed infested allotment plot 3 years ago. We covered entire plot in cardboard and black degradable mulch. We then made beds of green waste compost/manure on top of that so we could grow some stuff that season. We went round with a trowel a few times a week to remove any shoots coming through and covered a couple of bad patches in more cardboard. Second year we had a few shoots, third year none. We were meticulous about not letting it grow so weakening it all the time. There were existing fruit bushes on the plot. I did remove bindweed roots around them as much as possible, we then mulched with manure/compost and cardboard around them.

  12. #33801

    Nice to hear this Esther, you have done a great job and thanks for letting everyone know, in view of bindweed’s fearsome reputation!

  13. #33830

    Hi

    I took over a new plot in late July 2015 and have followed Charle’s advice. I had couch grass and bindweed and hopefully nothing worse. You can see a series of photos showing the effect of Charles’ advice by following this link

  14. #33833

    Thanks for posting this John, the images are clear, and yes you still have some couch and bindweed to die off. The compost and mypex will be effective I am sure.
    Looking ahead I imagine the neighbouring plot(s) have bindweed and couch? so you may need perhaps a long-term strip of mypex as border-path to reduce their entry to 248.

  15. #33847

    Great images John, and thanks Esther, gives me lots of inspiration.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)

Want to go further?

→ Free: Clearing weeds without digging