2027 Vegetable Sowing Calendar - Order now!
Read-only archive of the Charles Dowding forum, 2009–2019. For Charles’s latest advice, visit charlesdowding.co.uk.

Mustard and Carrots

Asked by RandA 23 April 2016 5 replies in Sowing and Growing

Charles answered Charles replied 2 times in this thread. Jump to his answer ↓

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  1. #34082

    Hi Charles
    I seem to remember reading somewhere that if you grow mustard plants near to carrots that confuses the carrot fly. Can anyone tell me if this is a good idea? I sowed carrots today and have some mustard in modules ready to plant out and thought they would go together but need some reassurance.

  2. #34086

    I would not do that but who knows! Often these things can be done in a year when the flies are absent so you can’t be sure if they work. Best of luck.

  3. #34089

    Charles
    Thanks for your reply, I think I will try and see what happens and of course tell you if it seems to work.
    Ali

  4. #34093

    Hi Ali,

    Much of what is said about these plant combinations is based on myth and legend with little or no scientific evidence to back it up.
    Don’t get me wrong though, I do believe that growing certain flowers/veg close to specific crops does benefit those crops. Certain flowers attract specific predatory insects/pollinators which are of course of benefit to us.
    On the specific question of the carrot fly you will often hear it suggested that growing Onions and Carrots together confuses the Carrot Fly. Unfortunately you need to grow a huge amount of Onions for the scent of the Onions to overwhelm the scent of the Carrots.
    The surest way to deal with the Carrot Fly is to sow bearing in mind the Fly’s life cycle. Sowing in late May or early June avoids the first generation. The second generation hatches circa September and the surest way to deal with that is to cover the crop with fleece.
    You will see it suggested that you should surround the crop with a 2′ high barrier of fleece or similar insect proof material. The theory behind that being that the Carrot fly cant fly that high. That may be the case but what happens if it gets blown higher on a windy day?
    This year I’m turning over one of my raised beds in the middle of my plot to growing cut flowers, following Monty Don’s example, though I will be concentrating more on insect attracting varities more than purely decorative varieties. I think it will be interesting to see how many varieties of insect it attracts.

    Don.

  5. #34095

    Don I think “science” struggles to understand gardening and nature.
    I once tried a few carrots among a whole bed of onions and they got the maggots.
    Also I think that the flies can hatch annoyingly outside those two times you mention.
    Also fleece is easily holed and mesh is better option as the flies seem to find any holes quite magically.

  6. #34102

    Hi Charles,
    Couldn’t agree with you more on science. A poor choice of words in this instance. I should perhaps have said factual evidence, I believe there is more art involved in gardening then science.
    The hatching times are of course weather dependant and we can all see how irratic/unpredictable our weather is becoming. As for them finding holes, I think the buggers have Radar!
    Don.

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)

Want to go further?

→ Free: Seeds & varieties Charles recommends