2027 Vegetable Sowing Calendar - Order now!
Read-only archive of the Charles Dowding forum, 2009–2019. For Charles’s latest advice, visit charlesdowding.co.uk.

Aminopyralid breakdown

Asked by Melody Gillespie 14 June 2018 1 reply in Sowing and Growing

Charles answered Charles replied once in this thread. Jump to his answer ↓

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  1. #47224

    Charles,

    My husband and I recently moved from the city (tiny garden) to the country (huge garden) and we were so happy to be able to make compost instead of buying it. We’ve spent the last 8 months working intensely on our new garden and greenhouse, most of which we had to dig out this week because of Aminopyralid contamination. In addition to the contaminated soil/compost/manure mix, we have a large (+4 cu yds) pile of horse manure (different source) that we planned on using after it aged for a couple of years. If this manure is contaminated as well, how long before we can be absolutely certain the Aminopyralid has broken down? I’m not sure I would trust any test I ran because of the termendous amount of work if I missed something. This is heartbreaking and certainly makes creating enough compost for a large, new garden much more difficult. We live in the Pacific Northwest (US) and as far as I can tell, there’s very little regulation of persistent herbicides here.

    I also want to thank you so much for the wonderful videos, books, and web site. I’ve learned so much from all of them.

    Melody

  2. #47225

    Hello Melody

    Thanks for writing, glad you like the videos.
    So sorry to hear of the contamination. It’s shameful that such a poison is allowed.
    It does not break down in heaps but does on soil, after affecting plants for a year or so. Bit of a lose-lose situation.
    I would trust a bean test, sow broad beans in manure from different parts of your heap.
    If growth is normal it’s ok, but any contamination will show as curled leaves etc.
    Sow a few beans in normal compost at the same time to match growth visually. Growth is not always ‘perfect’ in uncontaminated compost or soil.

    I wish you well in your new garden!

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)

Want to go further?

→ Free: Charles’s compost guide